The 7 Best Mailboxes 📫 [2021 Reviews & Guide]

Keep your mail secure while making your house look good, we review the top mailboxes

Our Editors independently research, test, and rate what we feel are the best products. We use affiliate links and may receive a small commission on purchases.

While most of us don’t get as much mail as we used to, you still need one for the mail and packages that you do get.

There are a lot of factors to consider when purchasing a new one, and countless options out there. You want a mailbox that looks good, is secure, and coordinates with your home’s colors and style.

We have done all the research

We’ve spent over the past few weeks testing and reviewing countless models to bring you the top mailboxes on the market today. Let’s get started!

Best Mailboxes

 Addresses of DistinctionMail Boss 7174 TownhouseMail Boss 7506 Manager
editors choice
Size:21" x 11" x 8.25"15.8" x 7.1" x 15"21" x 10.75" x 11.25"
Post Included:YesNoNo
Materials:AluminumElectro-galvanized SteelGalvanized Welded Steel
Access: FrontFrontFront

For more of my home & garden recommendations, have a look through these popular Outside Pursuits guide links: Patio Umbrellas, Outdoor Ceiling Fans, Patio Swings.

Quick Answer: The 7 Best Rated Mailboxes For 2021

  1. Addresses of Distinction Avenues Large Mailbox and Post
  2. Mail Boss 7174 Townhouse Locking Security Wall Mount Mailbox
  3. Mail Boss 7506 Manager Security
  4. Step2 531700 MailMaster StoreMore Mailbox
  5. Whitehall Products Black Deluxe Mailbox Package
  6. Highwood AD-MLBX1-ACE Hazelton Mailbox Post
  7. Simplay3 Classic Plastic Mount Mailbox

Our reviews to the top rated mailboxes with our comparison table and buyers guide will help you choose the right mailbox for you.

Mailbox Reviews


Addresses of Distinction Avenues Large Mailbox and Post at a Glance:

  • Size: 21″ x 11″ x 8.25″
  • Post Included: Yes
  • Materials: Aluminum
  • Locking: No
  • Access: Front

To start things off, we have the Addresses of Distinction Avenues Large Mailbox.

This one really is a looker, with a sophisticated appearance and everything you need for the mailman to find your location.

If you’re serious about adding curb appeal to your home or office, then this isn’t one to pass up.

The best mailbox for packages includes the box of course, along with a 6-foot ball finial post, decorative bracket accent, address plaque, address numbers, red aluminum flag, and all necessary hardware to assemble it.

The address numbers are a nice touch, and you can even message the manufacturer beforehand with your color preference and number selection.

Both the post and the mailbox are comprised of 100% rust-free, powder coated ¼” aluminum.

As it’s made from a single piece, you can count on it lasting throughout many years to come, even if you live in an area with extreme weather like blizzards and storms.

Painted black, it looks very sleek and elegant and is sure to turn some heads. Including a 1-year manufacturer’s warranty, you can rest easy knowing that it will perform as stated and that it will hold up well.

Mail Boss 7174 Townhouse Locking Security Wall Mount Mailbox at a Glance

  • Size: 15.8″ x 7.1″ x 15″
  • Post Included: No
  • Materials: Electrogalvanized Steel
  • Locking: Yes
  • Access: Front

Not everyone has the ability to have a mailbox out on the curb, while others simply prefer having theirs close to their front door.

Whatever your case may be, the Mail Boss 7174 Townhouse Locking Security Wall Mount Mailbox isn’t one to skip.

The best wall mount mailbox is rather plain in looks but evokes an old-school feel, coming in either Bronze, Black, Galaxy, Granite, or White.

Despite being mounted on the wall, it has a surprisingly large capacity, ensuring all of your deliveries get to you without a hitch.

Made of 14-gauge and 16-gauge electrogalvanized steel, it’s also inarguably one of the toughest, most durable out there.

Heavy winds, storms, and extreme temperatures are no match for the 7174 Townhouse. Stainless steel hinges and a powder-coated finish also ensure there’s no corrosion/rusting happening.

Featuring a patented anti-pry latch locking mechanism along with a 12-wafer disc lock, it’s going to be nearly impossible for would-be thieves to break in. If that weren’t enough, it even includes a vandal resistant flag!

Speaking of patented, their Fast-Trak mounting plate is as well. It’s one of the easiest mailboxes to install because of this plate, allowing for quick and seamless installation on already-existing posts in literally minutes.

Finally, you’ll also receive 3 keys, reflective house numbers, 4 lag bolts and a drill bit for installation. What more do you need?

Mail Boss 7506 Manager Security at a Glance:

  • Size: 21″ x 10.75″ x 11.25″
  • Post Included: No
  • Materials: 14-gauge/16-gauge Galvanized Welded Steel
  • Locking: Yes
  • Access: Front

Next up, we bring you the best waterproof mailbox: the Mail Boss 7506 Mail Manager Curbside Locking Security Mailbox.

Admittedly, the model isn’t much to look at and is a bit plain, visually speaking.

It does come in 4 different colors: Black, Bronze, Granite, and White, and will hold up against practically anything that comes its way.

The USPS-approved full-service locking security mailbox is perfect for residential areas as it prevents mail-identity theft as well as the stealing of any packages you may be receiving.

To do this, the box must be tough. That’s why this model came made of 14-and-16-gauge galvanized welded steel, complete with stainless-steel hinges to make it easier to use and hold up for longer.

To keep all your small parcels, letters, etc. safe, the baffle door eliminates fishing, while the anti-pry latch lock mechanism and 12-disc wafer lock ensure no one can leverage entry with a screwdriver.

This wafer is resistant against drills and picks, while the door lets packages in, but not hands.

Overall, this commercial-grade mailbox is perfect for keeping your mail safe so you don’t have to be nervous waiting and staring out the window for the mailman to arrive.

Step2 531700 MailMaster StoreMore Mailbox at a Glance:

  • Size: 28″ x 6.25″ x 13.25″
  • Post Included: No
  • Materials: Plastic
  • Locking: Yes
  • Access: Front or Back

The Step2 531700 MailMaster StoreMore Mailbox is the perfect choice in terms of looks and functionality.

The best locking mailbox features hidden doors and a lock to keep various sizes of parcels, envelopes, and more completely safe. Not only are they safe from prying hands and tools, but from harsh weather, too!

At first glance, you can tell that the 531700 is one of the most beautiful out there, with a realistic stone look that will have your neighbors jealous.

However, if you tend to receive a lot of packages or travel frequently, this is just the model for you. The “post” portion of the mailbox is actually a secret compartment.

Coming with a removable hidden access door, you can choose to keep it in place to act like a “regular” box or remove it to hold larger parcels.

To retrieve it, you can use either the front or the rear mail door. This ensures only someone with a designated key can take mail out.

Speaking of which, you’ll also receive 2 keys, address numbers, and mounting hardware. It does not come with a post, but mounts easily to a 4 x 4.

Whitehall Balmoral Mailbox at a Glance:

  • Size: 13.7″ x 13″ x 21″
  • Post Included: Yes
  • Materials: Aluminum Alloy
  • Locking: No
  • Access: Front

If you’re looking for simple but stylish, the Whitehall Balmoral Mailbox may be right up your alley.

With three different color options and address plaques, monogram and post included, you’ll have everything you need for setup in one package.

Right when you open up the box, you will see just how gorgeous it is. Sleek and shiny black with gold accents, this mailbox is sure to complement any house.

To ensure you get the correct numbers, simply let Whitehall know beforehand to customize your side plaques and if you’d like to add the name of your street.

One thing is for sure – having this mailbox will greatly boost the appearance of your home!

Made of die cast, high-density aluminum alloy, the mailbox and the post are incredibly durable and will easily withstand rough weather conditions.

To help extend the longevity, they’re also coated with an alumni-shield all-weather coating to protect against the elements.

Overall, this is a simple, elegant way to display your address and ensure your mail gets delivered to the right location.

Highwood AD-MLBX1-ACE Hazelton Mailbox Post at a Glance:

  • Size: 58″ x 5″ x 28″
  • Post Included: Yes
  • Materials: Stainless Steel
  • Locking: No
  • Access: Front

If you don’t live in a residential area, chances are you’re probably not going to need a complex or locking mailbox to receive parcels.

If you’re looking for something simple yet functional and good-looking, you can’t get better than the Highwood AD-MLBX1-ACE Hazelton Mailbox Post.

It gets the job done and will save you money while adding a bit of personality to your property.

The best rural mailbox is perfect if you live out in the middle of nowhere or don’t have any neighbors nearby.

The mailbox itself is made with durable 304 Grade stainless-steel hardware, ensuring it’s fade-resistant to keep its good looks.

The Weathered Acorn is a cool brown that is a lovely complement to lush trees and greenery.

However, you get to choose between an array of different post colors: Weathered Acorn (to match), Black, White, Charleston Green, Coastal Teak, Dried Sage, Toffee, and Tuscan Taupe.

The US-made product is completely weatherproof, ensuring no cracks nor peels, even in the blistering sun and frigid cold.

Setup is absolutely one of the easiest out there, and even comes with an assembly guide to further facilitate the process. There were a couple of reviewers who didn’t like the plastic post cap, but overall it’s an excellent buy.

Oh, and if you’re worried about durability, don’t be! It comes with a whopping 12-year residential limited warranty!

Simplay3 Classic Plastic Mount Mailbox at a Glance:

  • Size: 22″ x 12.5″ x 49.8″
  • Post Included: Yes
  • Materials: Plastic
  • Locking: No
  • Access: Front and Rear

Lastly, is the Simplay3 Classic Plastic Residential Mailbox and Post Mount Combo Kit. As one of the best residential mailboxes, you can expect it to look good, be easy to use, durable, and easy on the wallet.

Drawing inspiration from mailboxes from the “old days”, it offers a classic appearance that will look nice on any curb.

While the all-black is certainly nice, you can also choose between other color schemes: Black/White, Light Gray/Dark Gray, and White.

The model is very large and made to easily accommodate small-to-medium-size parcels, boxes, newspapers, magazines, and more.

There’s even a cool cherry red flag mail pick up indicator on the front which rotates 90 degrees out from the front mailbox door.

You’ll also find a rear mail door for added security and convenience. Both doors feature heavy duty magnets to keep them closed, along with extra-tough, double-wall construction to keep it in perfect condition.

Included stick-on numbers will help the delivery/mailman out with finding the right home while completing the look.

Installation is also simple, once the 4 x 4 post is installed. After that, all you need is a few more screws to put the mailbox together and finish off the process.

Best Mailbox Comparison Table

Best Mailboxes SizePost IncludedMaterialsLockingAccessRating
Addresses of Distinction21" x 11" x 8.25"YesAluminumNoFront4.4 / 5.0
Mail Boss 7174 Townhouse15.8" x 7.1" x 15"NoElectrogalvanized Steel
YesFront4.7 / 5.0
Mail Boss 750621" x 10.75" x 11.25"NoGalvanized Welded SteelYesFront4.7 / 5.0
Step2 531700 MailMaster28" x 6.25" x 13.25"NoPlasticYesFront or Back4.3 / 5.0
Whitehall Balmoral Mailbox13.7" x 13" x 21"YesAluminum AlloyNoFront4.5 / 5.0
Highwood AD-MLBX1-ACE58" x 5" x 28"YesStainless SteelNoFront4.4 / 5.0
Simplay3 Classic22" x 12.5" x 49.8"YesPlasticNoFront and Rear4.7 / 5.0

How to Choose the Best Mailbox – Buying Guide

best locking mailbox

Now that you have had the chance to read about everything you could ever want to know about some good mailboxes, have you narrowed it down to the perfect one for your home?

If you’re still a bit uncertain, there is no need to be worried. Who would’ve thought there were so many amazing mailboxes out there and so many variables?

We understand it can be confusing when there are so many excellent selections to choose from, which is why we’ve gone ahead and written up the following, user-friendly buying guide to help you out!


First off, you’ll probably want to consider the style of mailbox you’d like. As you can see from the above products, there are so many options to choose from!

You can go for modern, rustic, traditional, and the list goes on and on. You’ll want to consider your own, personal style as well as the existing style of your home and hope the two jive together.

If you have a beach house, you’re probably not going to want something harsh and modern and instead will want to go for a more natural look, for example.


Next up, you’ll need to look at the type of mailbox you want. There are those that are more traditional and made to be used with a post, while others can be mounted on a wall.

Wall-mounted models are ideal if you don’t like the idea of your mail sitting out on the curb and want it close to your front door instead, don’t have a designated curb area for a mailbox, or simply don’t or can’t walk all the way out there to fetch the mail.

Freestanding models are great if you need more space or if you just don’t want to mount the box on a wall.

Locked or Not?

You may be thinking that locked mailboxes are the only way to go, as they’re the most secure. While they may be a great option for some people, others don’t like the idea of only being able to open it up with a key.

Let’s face it, many of us out there aren’t going to remember to bring a key each time or may lose it.

Then what? If you live in a rural area especially, chances are you’re probably not going to need a locked mailbox and it may be more trouble than it’s worth.

On the other end of the spectrum, if you live in a residential area and are worried for your mail then go ahead and lock it up!


You may have noticed that the mailboxes on our guide are either made of a metal or of plastic. Aluminum alloy and steel are the most common in regards to metals, as they’re very durable and relatively inexpensive.

Steel will typically be slightly pricier than aluminum alloy, but it’s not a rule. It’s also resistant to rust, though will generally require an extra weather-proof coating to hold up against weather.

They’re also the most durable, though plastic is the most affordable and can also withstand quite a bit if thick and well-constructed enough.


Some models come with extras that may not cost a lot to purchase separately, but are always nice to have thrown in.

This often includes a flag to let your mailman know there’s mail in the box, included house numbers/street names, customization, keys, and more.


If you’re addicted to Amazon and always find yourself receiving packages in the mail, you’re probably going to need a larger capacity.

In contrast, if you only receive a few envelopes here and there then you can save some cash and opt for a smaller box.


How much do you feel comfortable spending on one a top rated mailbox? It’s a smart idea to think about this and come up with a number before you start shopping around as it can be easy to spend more than you wanted to.

There are plenty of very affordable options on our guide, and usually the more expensive ones will be the largest and come with a post.

FAQs About Best Mailboxes

Q: What is the best material for a mailbox?

A: Galvanized steel, much like what you’ll find on the Mail Boss 7174, is extremely durable and handles moisture exceptionally well.

Q: How far does a mailbox need to be off the road?

A: The USPS indicates that it must be 41-45 inches above the top of the road and 6-8 inches from the face of the curb or road edge. This is so the postal carrier can deliver the mail without having to get out of the vehicle.

Q: How high should a wall mounted mailbox be?

A: Generally, they must be installed at a height of 41–45 inches from the road surface to the bottom of the mailbox or point of mail entry.

Q: Can you leave outgoing mail in your mailbox?

A: Yes, you can. Just make sure that if your mailbox has multiple sections/slots that you place it in the designated space for outgoing mail.

Q: How do I prevent mailbox smashing?

A: Opt for a thick mailbox that isn’t easily smashed, like the thinner aluminum mailboxes can be. Adding a decoy mailbox can also help with this, or even adding on a protective casing made out of wood or metal.

Tips For Choosing a Mailbox

#1: If you live in an area that gets a lot of rain/snow and don’t often receive larger packages, get a wall-mounted box.

This way, you don’t have to worry about venturing out into harsh weather conditions and risk you and your mail getting wet.

#2: Make sure to always have a spare key handy.

Most locked mailboxes are going to come with 3 extra keys. You can give another to your significant other or housemate one, and keep an extra safe in case you lose one.

#3: Try to select a mailbox that goes with the look of your home.

There are plenty of gorgeous options, but you want one that has the same feeling that your home does and increases the curb appeal instead of looking awkward.

Final Thoughts

Now that you’ve read just about everything you could ever want to about the best security mailboxes on the market today, which one will you be installing at your home?

No matter which one you select, you can rest assured that you’re getting one of the best out there. However, what’s most important is that you select the model that fits your lifestyle and preferences perfectly.

We hope that our guide has helped you accomplish exactly that. Thanks for tuning in and we’ll see you again soon!

How We Researched

To come up with the top security mailboxes, we researched a variety of sources for reviews such as Home Depot, Lowes, Target and Wayfair  along with our own personal experience.

We also consulted online magazines for product research and reviews to get as much unbiased information as we could. To help weed out fake reviews we used to make sure we only looked at genuine reviews.

With so much quality gear available, we had to narrow it down based on what we felt were the best options were for the price. The staff authors have a wide and varied background in yard design and home repairs.

The authors have decades of experience and are eager to share their knowledge with readers.

To help narrow down the selection we used personal experiences along with recommendations from landscapers, bloggers and contractors.

After extensive research, we came up with our list to help you choose the right one for you.


Notice: is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program. earns fees from products sold through qualifying purchases by linking to Amazon offers a commission on products sold through their affiliate links.

Shayanne Weeks

Shayanne is a freelance writer and marketer based in LA, California. Describing herself as a nomad, she has lived in Boise, Idaho and Seattle, Washington as well as Guadalajara, Mexico. As an extremely active person, she loves to snowboard, skateboard, and ski. She enjoys sharing her love for active sports with others through her “how to” sports guides and sports equipment reviews. Shyanne is addicted to the adrenaline rush she experiences during her outdoor pursuits, from ziplining in Mexico to snowboarding in Idaho.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top button