Pets & Training

The 7 Best Dog Training Shock Collars Reviewed – 2020

Dogs are some of the world’s most amazing creatures, but sometimes training them can be quite the challenge. One of the most effective ways of doing so is through the use of dog training collars.

However, the collar needs to be one of the best – safe, effective, comfortable, and convenient.

That’s why we’ve spent over the past month researching and reviewing countless products to bring you the very best dog training collars on the market today!

Best Dog Training Collars

 Garmin Delta XC BundlePATPET Shock CollarDogtra Remote Training Collar
editors choice
Range:1/2 mile3000 ft.3/4 mile
Levels:1816127
Battery Life:60-70 hours3 - 6 days10 hours
Waterproof:YesYesYes

For more of my top dog product recommendations, have a look through these popular Outside Pursuits guide links: Dog Crates & Kennels, Electric Fences, Dog Houses, Dog Car Seats.

Quick Answer: The 7 Best Rated Dog Training Collars For 2020

  1. Garmin Delta XC Bundle
  2. PATPET Shock Collar for Dogs IPX7
  3. Dogtra 1902S Two Dogs Remote Training Collar
  4. Bousnic Dog Training Collar 2 Dogs
  5. Garmin Sport PRO Bundle
  6. Dr. Trainer Dog Training Collar
  7. SportDOG Brand Family Remote Trainers

Our reviews to the top rated dog training shock collars with our comparison table and buyers guide will help you choose the right dog collar for you.


Dog Training Collars Reviews

You may know Garmin from their GPS devices, but they also make some amazing dog training collars, like their Delta XC.

The model is simple but straightforward and effective to make training as easy as possible. Even if you’re brand-new to the devices, thanks to its user-friendliness you don’t have to worry about it being difficult.

When you receive your package, you’ll find a compact 3-button handheld controller unit which features a nice LCD display that’s good-sized and easy to read.

Expand To See More

While you’ll only receive one collar in the package, if you have more dogs, you can use the controller to train up to 3 dogs! What’s more, is that the controller comes with a water rating of IPX7 so you’re not limited when and where you use it!

With 18 levels of momentary and continuous stimulation along with changeable contact points (both long and short) along with tone and vibration you’ll see results even just after one use.

Working with distances up to half a mile, they’re great for use in large yards or even out in the field/wilderness!

The best electric dog collar also comes with 3 different correction/training configurations to use for various behavioral issues. All that and listed at relatively affordable price? What do you have to lose?

 

Garmin Delta XC Bundle at a Glance:

  • Range: 1/2 mile
  • Stimulation Levels: 18
  • Battery Life: 60-70 hours
  • Waterproof: Yes

PATPET Shock Collar for Dogs - IPX7 Waterproof Dog Shock Collar

If you’re on the hunt for one of the best dog training shock collars but don’t want to spend a lot on it, then we have good news for you.

The PATPET Shock Collar for Dogs is a budget-friendly option that is perfect if you don’t need it for long distances. On top of that, it’s rated at IPX7 waterproof, so you can use it just about anywhere you want!

Despite being so affordable, it’s surprisingly super convenient, with the battery lasting the longest out of most competitor products.

Expand To See More

The built-in rechargeable lithium battery takes 2 hours to charge and an impressive 3 to 6 days, with the remote lasting up to 6 to 12 days.

The remote features a clear LCD display with a range of up to 3000 feet, which is ideal for backyard or park use.

The conductors are soft and much safer than competitor products, with thicker and longer contact points to make for better skin contact.

Instead of metallic conductors which can rust or cause pain to your dog, these are made of conductive silicone.

The touch distinguishing design uses different surface designs on buttons and a concave-convex design around the button. This makes it easy to send training commands without having to actually look at the transmitter.

There are 3 different training modes included, and the shock can be adjusted from 1 to 16 with beep, vibration, and shock alerts.

 

PATPET Shock Collar for Dogs IPX7 at a Glance:

  • Range: 3000 ft.
  • Stimulation Levels: 16
  • Battery Life: 3 – 6 days
  • Waterproof: Yes

If price isn’t of that much importance to you but you want the absolute best quality possible, then check out the Dogtra 1902S Remote Training Collar.

This model comes with everything you need and more to train your dog quickly and efficiently. Coming with the remote training collar and PetsTEK clicker, it works best for dogs from 35 pounds and up.

The collar is one of the most comfortable out there, as it’s slim and ergonomically designed to fit your dog’s neck without problems, so long as their neck is between 6 and 26 inches.

Expand To See More

It’s also waterproof, meaning that they can run around in the rain or puddles without risking damage to the device.

Working up to ¾ of a mile, it’s one of the more flexible models in terms of distance, too. The waterproof receiver lets you select anywhere up to 127 levels, ranging from low to high, which is a variety practically unseen even in the best devices.

You can also switch up the sensitivity of the collar, such as Momentary Nick Mode to give just one pulse, or Constant Stimulation Mode if they’re not paying attention which will send a continuous signal up to 12 seconds.

It’s easy to see why this is the best dog shock collar!

 

Dogtra 1902S Two Dogs Remote Training Collar at a Glance:

  • Range: 3/4 mile
  • Stimulation Levels: 127
  • Battery Life: 10 hours
  • Waterproof: Yes

 

Next up is the Bousnic Dog Training Collar which is another excellent budget buy. If you’re trying to score one of the best training collars for small dogs, medium dogs, or large dogs, then keep on reading.

While it only works in areas up to 1000 feet, it’s ideal if you’re looking to train them in your backyard or at smaller distances such as at the park.

What we really appreciated about this model was that it was obviously effective, but that the manufacturer placed particular importance on it being safe and humane.

Expand To See More

You can choose from up to 16 Static Shock modes, up to 8 Vibration modes, and a standard “Tone” mode. Completely customize them to fit your dog’s temperament perfectly.

What’s more, is that you can choose to train up to 2 dogs simultaneously if you need to! The remote comes with a dual channel and there are two collars included which make this possible.

Each collar is rated IP67 waterproof, so your pups can even go for a swim or run around the pool without issue!

Speaking of remotes, the easy-access button sizes and straightforward format make it one of the most user-friendly models out there, making it simple to train your dog and help them learn commands quicker.

With the Lithium-Polymer batteries lasting up to a whopping 20 days, this will be one of the best training experiences your dogs can have.

If that weren’t enough, Bousnic even throws in a 1-year worry-free warranty and will replace or refund you if you have any issues!

 

Bousnic Dog Training Collar 2 at a Glance:

  • Range: 1000 feet
  • Stimulation Levels: 16
  • Battery Life: 15-20 days
  • Waterproof: Yes

Garmin Sport PRO Bundle, Dog Training Collar

We’re back yet again with another amazing product from Garmin. We just can’t deny the cutting-edge technology that makes the training process easier, along with the reliability we’ve come to expect from the manufacturer.

The Sport PRO Bundle even lets you train up to 3 dogs at once, making it one of the most convenient products we’ve had the chance to use!

Let’s be real – dog training can be a handful and you may not always have both hands available to best training collar for small dogs and medium size dogs properly.

Expand To See More

Thanks to the quick turn dial with positive clicks when changing between the 10 stimulation levels and auxiliary functions, you only need to use one hand!

In fact, you don’t even have to be looking at it to know what you’re doing!

This one comes with 4 training buttons as opposed to most which come with 3. This lets you switch between continuous or momentary stimulation, vibration, and tone.

The buttons on the remote let you activate the tone signal and control vibration frequency and intensity.

While most options only allow you to train your dog during the day, the LED beacon lights on your pup’s device allow you to work with them in low-light conditions, too!

The lights are even visible up to an impressive 100 yards away! The only downside is that it works up to just 1000 feet, so if you need something with more distance, you may want to opt for another model.

 

Garmin Sport PRO Bundle at a Glance:

  • Range: 3/4 mile
  • Stimulation Levels: 10
  • Battery Life: 60 hours
  • Waterproof: Yes

The Dr. Trainer Dog Training Collar is truly one-of-a-kind, coming with advanced technology rarely seen in other collars.

You’ll be able to fully customize your and your dog’s experience thanks to an array of unique features. Working on an array of dog sizes, breeds, and temperaments, this is an excellent selection for many consumers.

With this best electric dog collar, you’ll find that the remote has an auto retractable feature which means you can train your dogs without having to cause them pain.

Expand To See More

Retractable silicone prongs are nice and soft, leaving them irritation-free. What really stands out here is the built-in voice-recording chip which allows you to customize and personalize the command given.

This has been suggested to improve training efficiency, and you can choose to change them at any time you feel like. No more having to deal with monotonous or annoying beeps!

As the shock collar is rated at IP67 waterproof, you can train them, rain, shine, or pool. The remote can also be locked up so there’s no risk of giving commands you didn’t’ want to.

The clear, good-sized LCD display is also convenient, making it simple to see the settings you have it placed on.

Finally, you’ll love that it comes with a 100% money back guarantee along with an impressive 2-year warranty!

 

Dr. Trainer Dog Training Collar at a Glance:

  • Range: 2600 feet
  • Stimulation Levels: 10
  • Battery Life: 15-20 days
  • Waterproof: Yes

Taking on the prestigious title of “Amazon’s Choice”, it’s no wonder why the SportDOG Brand Remote Trainer is so popular.

It’s not the cheapest product out there, but it’s quite a bit more affordable than many competitor products. Despite this, it is packed with an array of special features you and your furry friend are sure to love.

Capable of working up to 500 yards, you can train your dog in an array of places that they love without worry. In fact, it’s not even just limited to one dog!

Expand To See More

Train up to 3 at once with the remote, though it’s important to note that you will have to purchase extra collars as this kit only comes with one.

The straightforward product comes with 21 different static stimulation levels, available in either momentary nick mode or continuous mode. You can select between vibration and tone, which can get a bit boring but still works well.

Not only is this trainer waterproof, but it’s actually submersible up to 25 feet thanks to the brand’s DryTek technology! If it accidentally falls in the pool or something, then you can still recover it!

Lithium ion rechargeable batteries are extra-convenient, taking just 2 hours to fully charge and providing up to 70 hours of run-time, which is pretty impressive.

This is one of the best dog training collars is definitely not one to skip over.

 

SportDOG Brand Family Remote Trainers at a Glance:

  • Range: 500 yards
  • Stimulation Levels: 21
  • Battery Life: 50 – 70 hours
  • Waterproof: Yes

Dog Training Collar Comparison Table

Dog Shock Collars RangeLevelsBattery LifeWaterproofRating
Garmin Delta XC Bundle1/2 mile18n/aYes4.1 / 5.0
PATPET Shock Collar3000 ft.163 - 6 daysYes4.8 / 5.0
Dogtra 1902S Training Collar3/4 mile12710 hoursYes4.6 / 5.0
Bousnic Dog Training Collar 21000 feet1615-20 daysYes4.4 / 5.0
Garmin Sport PRO Bundle3/4 mile1060 hoursYes4.5 / 5.0
Dr. Trainer Dog Training Collar2600 feet1015-20 daysYes4.2 / 5.0
SportDOG Remote Trainers500 yards2150 - 70 hoursYes4.2 / 5.0

How to Choose the Best Dog Training Collar – Buying Guide

best dog training collar
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers

Now that you’ve had the opportunity to read all about the best dog training collars, have you decided which is the perfect catch for your pup? If not, that’s okay! We’re here to help!

We’ve taken it upon ourselves to write up the detailed buying guide below to ensure that you’re 100% satisfied with your decision. Go through each step of the selection process for best results. Let’s get started!

Size

It doesn’t matter if you have the absolute best training collar in the world if it doesn’t fit your best friend. Of course, this is going to be determined by the size of your dog’s neck.

To properly measure the size, try to find a collar for your dog to try on and attempt to fit your two fingers between the collar and their neck. If you can do it with no problem, then it’s the correct size. You shouldn’t be able to fit more than that, though!

best shock collar for large dogs
Dogtra 1900S / 1902S Remote Training Collar

Distance Range

How big is your yard or the area in which your dog plays or roams? Try to figure this out before anything else as well. The range of the collar will determine how far you can use the device with your dog.

The vast majority of collars seem to work anywhere from half a mile to a mile. Most users won’t need anything more than that, anyway.

Training Modes

You’ve probably noticed by now that the number of available training modes per device varies hugely. The lowest number you’ll find is typically around 10, which isn’t much variety and may not be as effective on your dog.

The average number lies around 15-20 which has been proven to work well, though there are a few select models which go up to well over 100 modes! This is particularly impressive and will undoubtedly yield the best and quickest results, as each animal is different and responds differently.

best dog training shock collar
Bousnic Dog Training Collar 2 Dogs

Battery Life

Battery life also varies quite a bit, with some only lasting around 10 hours and others up to almost a week! Think about realistically how long you’re going to be using it for at once, and if you’ll also be able to charge it easily in-between sessions.

If you don’t have a lot of time to wait, then you may want to go for a model that holds a charge for at least a few days at a time. These are also much more convenient, as you can just get training done with and be more consistent without having to stop to charge for a couple of hours.

Speed and Reliability

For dog training to be effective, your pup must be able to associate the stimulation from the training collar with the behavior you’re trying to stop them from doing.

That means that the stimulation must be delivered as quickly as possible after you trigger it. To do this, however, your setup requires a fast and reliable wireless connection between the remote and the collar(s).

While there are a couple great budget products on our guide, they tend to be just a bit slower, so if you can wing it, spending a few extra bucks may just be worth it.

Waterproof

The good news is, that every training collar kit on our guide is waterproof. That means that your dog can play around in the water without risk of damaging anything or hurting itself.

However, the amount of “waterproof-ness” varies per product, so think about the kind of water your pup may encounter. Do they like playing around in your swimming pool or taking dips in a pond or lake? Then you’ll definitely need absolute waterproof-ness.

If they’re just going to be playing in the rain or sometimes get a bit of water on them from their water bowl, then this isn’t quite as necessary.

best electric dog collar
PATPET Shock Collar for Dogs – IPX7 Waterproof Dog Shock Collar

Types of Tones

While the vast majority of models just come with vibration and tone, there is one on our guide (the Dr. Trainer) which goes above-and-beyond and even lets you record your own voice commands! This is particularly special as we all know how well our dogs respond to our voices.

This could suggest more effective training as they feel like they’re listening to you instead of random beeps and whatnot. Plus, beeping over and over can get annoying pretty quickly!

Price

How much money are you realistically okay with spending on one of the best dog training collars? Try to come up with a solid number or budget range and stick to that to avoid any buyer’s remorse.

You’ll find the most affordable ones clock in at around $50 – $60 where others are up to $250. When you go up in price, you’ll typically get more intensity levels, different command modes, a longer battery life, and the ability to train more than one dog at once.

FAQs About Dog Training Collars

Q: How can I create a fenceless boundary with my dog?

A: Many people like to use electric fences, but we feel that those aren’t necessary and can even be a bit dangerous. Instead, determine what the boundaries will be. When your dog starts getting close to the boundary, make sure to set off a little shock. The results will vary per dog and breed, but it will usually just take a few times of doing this for your dog to realize that that’s not something they enjoy feeling, and will stay inside their boundaries.

Q: Do these collars hurt dogs?

A: No, they shouldn’t. In fact, the idea is that they’re nice and comfortable for your pup until they perform an undesired behavior. When that happens, there willl be a little nick or shock, but these will be more about discomfort than actual pain.

Q: How long will I have to use the training collar on my dog?

A: This one is just too hard to give one generic answer to, as all dogs are different. This may vary between dog breeds, backgrounds, age, and your relationship with your dog. Though, in general, a few weeks to a month of use is usually more than enough to see sufficient results.

Q: Will two dogs of different sizes respond the same to the training collars?

A: Most likely, no. For example, if you have a Chihuahua and a Husky, you’re probably going to need a higher intensity level for the latter as they’re much bigger and also have more fur between their skin and the collar. To figure out which stimulation level to start at, first try it out on yourself. If you start feeling a stinging sensation, then make note of the level you have it set at. If it’s, for example, at an 8, then set it around 4 as dog’s are more sensitive than we are!

Tips For Choosing Dog Training Collars

#1: To start out with the training collar, try taking your dog on a walk.

This is a great way to introduce them to the collar as you’ll be in a calm situation that they should already be pretty familiar with. You can use them more regularly when they’re out in the yard or at the park, and to solidify their training, take them to a dog park where there are a lot of distractions around.

#2: Make sure to eventually transition them to a regular collar.

While it’s not absolutely necessary, you’ll often see better results if you reward your pup for their good behavior with a treat. If they start to revert back to their old habits, then you should have no problem putting back the training collar on them and make sure you’re being consistent.

#3: Never use a training collar on a puppy that’s less than 10 weeks old.

Instead of seeing positive results, you’re most likely going to traumatize your puppy, though positive reinforcement with treats is never a bad idea. You can also use a leash at this time if they’re escaping or not listening to your commands.

Summary

Now that you’ve had the opportunity to read just about everything you could ever want to learn regarding the best dog training collars, have you decided which one is best for you and your dog?

Know that while each product on our guide is one of the best in the world, what’s most important is that you select the product ideal for your furry friend’s needs and yours. We hope that our guide has helped you do exactly that. Thanks for tuning in, and we’ll see you again shortly!

Performance
Features
Value

The Garmin Delta XC is our Editor's Choice for the best dog training collar with its performance, features and value.

User Rating: Be the first one !

Notice:

OutsidePursuits.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program. OutsidePursuits.com earns fees from products sold through qualifying purchases by linking to Amazon.com. Amazon offers a commission on products sold through their affiliate links.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top button
Close